James Potter

drjuliehoward drjuliehoward at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 14 16:51:45 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 88691

> 
> I agree, and it even leads me more into the James mystery. In the
> movies and if I remember correctly, in the book, We never actually 
see
> the scene of James' death. Maybe its because he was not in the same
> room or maybe because he was defending them at the entrance, I 
don't
> know exactly. But that makes me wonder what is up with James's 
death?
> We know he died because JKR said that BOTH of Harry's parents were
> dead and never coming back, but if James' death was mentioned, it 
was
> not stressed upon like Lily's. I mean his death should have the
> protection like you have said, but only Harry was the one anyhow 
and
> only he could stop Voldemort that night. But for some reason his 
death
> just doesn't seem as important as Lily's, and I wonder why since he
> was doing practically the same thing as Lily was, protecting 
someone.
> Maybe I am making too much of it, but I am getting too paranoid 
about
> what is a clue to think straight anymore :P

Julie:
I have been looking for a connection between the deaths of James and 
Lily and the continuous emphasis on Lily/Harry's eyes.  Lily exelled 
at charms.  Can this be done through eyes, without wand?  If so, 
perhaps this is why her death is of more importance.  She was in the 
room with Harry, facing Voldemort.  Any other thoughts?






More information about the HPforGrownups archive