At what time is a witch/wizard categorized as one?

ghinghapuss rredordead at aol.com
Fri Jan 16 00:10:18 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 88855

> Julie wrote:
> Do we have canon evidence that this is WHY dear old Uncle Algie 
> dropped Neville off the balcony?  Was it to see IF he was magical, 
> or does canon tell us simply that this is when they found out he 
was magical?  <snip> I still wonder about Neville's family and their 
> possibly being DEs or at least in this camp.  Is it possible that 
> Uncle Algie knew of LV's suspicion about the prophecy and, thinking 
> Neville could be the question mark, tried to kill Neville for LV?  


Mandy here:
Humm you're right.  It is Neville's assumption that his uncle dropped 
him to see if he was magical, or that's what Neville was lead to 
believe by his family.  

They could have had other motives.  I too am very suspictious of 
Neville's family, although I hadn't thought about the possiblity of 
DE/Uncle Algie knowing about part of the prophecy and attempting to 
kill Neville for LV.  Very interesting. 

mandy.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive