CH9 discussion questions -- the twins

[jdr0918]

No: HPFGUIDX 88939

<<<In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Kevin Lano" wrote: Despite 
appearing identical, people seem to have no trouble telling them 
apart when they're near them (except Molly at the start of PS!)>>

The Sergeant Majorette says:

Exactly so, except that I believe Molly *can* tell them apart. They 
were messing with her. She probably always blows them off when they 
do this. If it came to it making an actual difference which one is 
which, Molly would deal accordingly; but it will likely be something 
serious. (on a lighter note, in those "Which Twin is Gay?" polls that 
are so much fun, the same characteristics are cited, but the 
conclusions go either way: e.g., It's George because he's quieter/ 
It's Fred because he's louder...)

There's another thing: in OoP, it's *George* who says that he thinks 
they're "well shut of" Percy. Given that George seems to be the more 
mature of the two, doesn't this seem like a hint that Percy really 
*is* really Evil?

--JDR