Hermione and the D.A. List

[suehpfan]

No: HPFGUIDX 88957

Bobby wrote:
>> If you reply that it wasn't her copy of the list but one that the 
 Room of Requirement provided Umbridge (since the room provides 
 whatever is needed and Umbridge needed that), there is still a 
 problem.  Wouldn't JKR have Hermione the next day say something 
 like "It's not my list!  Mine is still in my room!" or "The list 
 vanished from my room!"?  The way the scene is written she 
 apparently pinned her copy to the wall, and DD ended up fired.>>


At the first DA meeting "She pinned the piece of paper with all of 
their names on it on the wall and wrote DUMBLEDORE'S ARMY across the 
top in large letters." OotP pg. 392 American Edition.  Hermione 
pinned it on the wall and never took it down.  They left the room the 
way it was when they were done.

Sue (who has faith that at least 90% of the students knew Umbridge 
was evil from the first day, dispite how "lovely" Percy thought she 
was.)