Lost wands
moviebec
moviebec at ihug.com.au
Mon Jan 19 07:27:49 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89106
> Geoff wrote:
> Try some wandless magic or borrow a friend's wand and do "Accio
wand"?
>
> Berit replies:
> Or, if you've misplaced your wand in the dark nearby; say "Lumos"
and voila, it lights up (like Harry did in the dementor scene in
Little Whinging :-)
>>>
-Snip-
Frost:
Somehow, I just don't think the Lumos would work normally. Well,
maybe... ok, what I'm thinking is this:
1) Super Adrenalin. If that wasn't a moment where adrenalin would
rush through the blood, I don't know what is. As it is, we don't
really know how adrenaline effects magic, but we do know how it
effects the body, which includes sharpening of the senses and a sort
of ability to hyper-concentrate on what is at hand. Since we know
that magic does need concentration, it is likely that Harry's (and
any other wizards) magical abilities might be a bit heightened at
that moment, like strength is in everyone.
2) His hand was inches from the wand. So it is possible that the
close proximity allowed for the wand to received the magical command
as well. We don't know what would have happened, say, it had been
several feet away.
-Snip-
-Bec-
We know that magic in untrained children, manifests itself when the
child is feeling heightened emotions or their life is in danger. For
example Neville bouncing when dropped out the window, Harry
disapparating when being chased at school by Dudley and his gang and
reapparating to a safe vantage point are just a few (though he didn't
realise at the time it was magic).
We also know that powerful witches and wizards don't have to use
their wands to perform magic but instead make things happen with
their will(mind power). Dumbledore comes to mind however I can't think
of any canon to concrete my beleif on this one. Can anyone else?
Here's my theory as to what happened to Harry in the alley that
night when his wand lit up even though he was not physically holding
the wand.
I believe that wands and incantations are simply tried and true ways
of performing magic, if you will, a vessel through which to harness
the power of the magic, a way to combine one's will and magical
ability. When Harry said the incantation he was desperately trying to
find his dropped wand so he could perform the patronus charm to drive
the dementors away. Therefore saying lumos actually made his wand
light up even though there was no physical contact. This is very
similar to Frosts adrenaline theory.
With this theory in mind one could, focusing their will, use
the "accio wand" spell have their wand return to them, depending on
how gifted the wizard or witch in question was.
What does everyone else think?
Bec
thought of the day;
Move forward fearlessly,
trusting that each step is perfectly guided!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive