Marauding Rita

Peter Felix Schuster pfsch at gmx.de
Mon Jan 19 13:46:48 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 89117

Hi Marianne!

> Marianne responds:
> I don't think Rita had anything to do with MWP becoming Animagi.  
> When Remus speaks of it in PoA, he seems to imply that the boys 
> figured it out on their own. Plus, Peter needed help from James and 
> Sirius to succeed in this. No mention of Rita.  
Peter again:
I doubt it could be learnt from books totally, so there could've been 
practical lessons, too. But most probably you're right.

> Peter:
> > Who's responsible in the MoM for registering animagi anyway? 
> Well, I wonder if this is all on the honor system.  If someone 
> figured out how to become an Animagus,  how would whoever was 
> responsible in the MoM for registering these people know?  I mean, 
> unless there was some method of tracing budding Animagi, how would 
> the MoM have any clue?
Peter again:
Well, they have methods to find out about underage magic as well. 
Since there seems to be a high risk from animagi, why not use those 
methods to them as well? In case that had it didn't work too well. If 
you don't risk being detected why register anyway? Worse thought of 
mine maybe....

Bye Peter






More information about the HPforGrownups archive