Why didn't Harry go to Grimmauld Place?
meriaugust
meriaugust at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 19 20:48:56 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89150
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, abbet69 at y... wrote:
> Why didn't Harry just go to Grimmauld Place instead of just
sticking
> his head in the fire. He could have checked the house for Sirius
and
> if he wasn't in the house, at least he was in London by himself
> without putting his friends in danger. I don't think there's any
> reason not to believe Harry could use the Floo Network from
Umbridge
> office.
>
> Abbet
The simple answer to your question is that JKR says so: she needed
to get Harry to the Ministry of Magic, duel with the DE's, loose his
godfather and learn about the prophecy, and she did so in v.
dramatic fashion. If Harry had just leapt into the kitchen at Number
12, waltzed upstairs and found Sirius tending to Buckbeak's wounds,
then we would have been denied a great battle sequence, the tragic
death of a great character and the most important chapter in HP
cannon: The Lost Prophecy. But the answer you are looking for is
slightly more difficult. The simple fact of the matter is that Harry
is, for all intents and purposes, a fifteen year old boy, and the
more complex fact of the matter is that there is no easy way to
understand how the brain of a fifteen year old boy works (trust me,
I live with one who hasn't the sense to come out of the rain). There
are lots of things that Harry *should* do but doesn't. There are
dozens of incidents in the books in which our boy hero finds himself
in a situation where a simple solution (one that the readers are
probably screaming out at him) would have saved him a lot of bother
and trouble and drastically changed the course of the novels. For
exampe, in GoF, after he has figured out the egg clue and is stuck
in the stairs under the invisibility cloak with his Marauder's Map
just out of reach, I know I was screaming "Accio Harry! Accio you
idiot!" Had he done that, he could have retrieved both the map and
the egg, and kept Fake!Moody from using the map in the plot to kill
his father. My point, and I do apoloize for being so long winded, is
that sometimes the obvious solution doesn't occur to Harry, or to
anyone that age. Plus it also sacrifices plot points.
Meri (who after seeing Return of the King is sure Frodo and Sam took
the long way around, and could have gotten to Mordor faster though
without all that good plot and character development)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive