Fawkes

Dalriada dalriada26 at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 21 16:48:27 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 89335

Snip
> lizvega2:
> Actually I'd like to see canon supporting that Fawkes came with the
> office. In COS, (Sorry, no reference I'm at work) Harry enters Tom
> Riddle's 'memory' and finds himself in the Headmaster's office. He
> makes a note of the fact that this office does not belong to
> Dumbledore yet, and he specifically says there's no Fawkes there.
Snip

Dally here:
So, based on the memory in COS, Fawkes may not come with the 
specific office, but with the position of Headmaster. In the 
previously quoted essay by Phyllis D. Morris, she asks "If we accept 
the premise that Fawkes was once Gryffindor's phoenix, it raises the 
interesting question of who might have owned Fawkes between the time 
of Gryffindor's death and when Dumbledore assumed responsibility for 
him." Morris then speculates that Fawkes may have been cared for by 
the Druidess Cliodna. 

I just wanted to clear up what I meant when I said "According to the 
Lexicon" in my original post. Morris doesn't have exact page number 
references to support her theories, but they sound fairly reasonable 
to me.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive