Is HP related to Voldemort?
ilubom
irina_l_ at hotmail.com
Fri Jan 23 08:32:54 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89447
Hi everyone,
Just want to start off by saying "hello", I'm new here.
I've got this theory that is bugging me at the moment. Is it
possible that Harry is related to Voldemort? There are some parts of
books that suggest he may be:
1. HP looks like LV/Tom Riddle did in his youth - this is mentioned
several times in CoS, including by Riddle.
2. The fact that LV, upon hearing of the prophesy went after Harry
and not Neville - who is a "pureblood". Dumbledore actually mentions
that for LV a "pureblood" wizard is the only one that is worth being
or knowing. If that is the case, why did he assume that Harry was
the one who would be his nemesis? If he knew that Harry was related
to him it would explain him deciding that Harry may have the same
sort of power.
3. LV was reluctant to kill Lily - he only killed her because she
would not get out of the way. When LV is speaking through Quirrell
he says that Harry's mother need not have died. Why wouldn't he want
to kill her if she was working against him - he is not exactly a
humanitarian! (on the other hand he thought nothing of killing his
father and grandparents so even if Lily was a relative it should
not have influenced him).
4. The comment made by the Sorting Hat that Harry had Slytherin's
power in him and would do well in that house. As LV is the "heir of
Slytherin" it may suggest a commonality of blood (although what DD
says about LV transferring his power to Harry when he failed to kill
him may also provide an explanation.
5. It would fit well with the theme of bad relatives (eg Dursleys,
Bellatrix and Sirius, Weasleys and Percy, etc)
What do people think?
Cheers
IL
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive