Is Snape a pureblood? and a few other bits Ive been concerned about
Bridget
blondeangelkiss at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 23 22:16:15 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89518
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Hitomi"
<japanesesearcher at y...> wrote:
> curlyshirleywhirley wrote:
> > <Snip>
> And, as we also know, Snape knew about Quirrell and LV, and
> continually threatened Quirrell, and once defied him by saving
> Harry's life. LV probably believed Snape had changed sides, which
> is why I don't understand how LV can't at least suspect Snape to
be
> a traitor. Snape walks a very line, and since Rowling has told us
> to watch out for him in interviews, I'm not entirely sure whether
or
> not he can be trusted, even though DD and Hermione both do. Guess
> we'll have to wait and see.
I have A theory about why Voldy doesn't suspect Snape after the
Voldy/Quirrell Stuff: Snape didn't or at least wasn't supposed to
know that Voldemort was the reason Quirrell was trying to steal the
Stone and kill Harry. He obvioulsy knew Quirrell was a bad guy and
tried to stop him, but that doesn't mean he knew Voldy was involced.
Maybe I missed it, but I don't remember there being anything saying
that Snape knew about Voldemort. Although I do think snape is
incredibly intelligent and may have figured out what was going on, I
don't believe he let on to know about Voldy if he did know.
Therefore he could conceivably go to Voldy and say something to the
effect of "Master I didn't realize he was working for you, otherwise
i wouldn't have interfered." And would then be welcome back w/ open
arms. If Snape did know, we don't know that Voldy knew Snape knew.
If I've missed anything in the books that says Snape knew about
Voldy being involved and that Voldy knew that Snape knew, please let
me know, cause I haven't seen anything to implicate that, (although
i do tend to get excited while reading the HP books and sometimes
skip paragraphs to get to the exciting stuff faster so and its
possible that I just missed it.) But unless there is reason to
beilieve that Snape knew and that Voldy knows he knew, there is no
reason for Voldy to not let Snape back in as a DE.
-Bridget (
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive