????? Relativity

[meriaugust]

No: HPFGUIDX 89574

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dms31865" <dms31865 at y...> 
wrote:
> Could Crookshanks be Harry's grandfather? Just trying to decifer 
if 
> Dumbledore could be related, too, for he had the invisiblilty 
cloak. 
> Thanks for letting me post my first one.
> 
> "dms31865"

There has been a lot of speculation as to who, if anyone, 
Crookshanks could be an animagus form for, from Dumbledore to 
Mungdungus Fletcher. IMHO, this theory has one major flaw. The witch 
at the Magical Menagerie tells Hermione in PoA that Crockshanks has 
been there for ages. Now, admittedly Peter Pettigrew stayed in rat 
form for over tweleve years, but he had a good reason to do so. 
IMHO, there is no good reason for one of Harry's grandparents to 
spend so much time as a cat. And as to DD having the invisibility 
cloak, I think that we will see in the next two books (more so than 
we have in the past, anyway) how close DD was to the Potters, though 
not nessicarily related. From them being members of the Order 
together, to how highly DD speaks of both Lily and James, I can see 
James leaving a few things in DD's possession, just in case. 
Meri (who would be a little creeped out if she were a Gryffindor 
girl and Crookshakns turned out to be an elderly man)