Protection for EVERYONE at Hogwarts
lizvega2
lizvega2 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 27 20:43:13 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 89800
I'm remembering the scene in OOP where Umbridge is trying to boot
Trelawney. Dumbledore didn't seem at all perturbed by Umbridge
sacking Trelawney, only that she was trying to remove her from the
castle. We learn at the end of OOP that, as far as DD knows, the
woman has given two predictions. Two predictions yield sixteen years
of income and security teaching a subject that DD wasn't sure he
even wanted to continue at Hogwarts. IMO, Hermione and McGonagall
are right in their estimation of the subject: it's rubbish. I think
DD keeps Trelawney at the castle for her protection. LV's informant
was thrown from the Hog's Head half way through the prophecy, but
surely he/she saw who was giving it! Pretty good reason for DD to
give Trelawney a job all these years isn't it?
Snape. DE, or reformed? Regardless of the speculation, all we know
about him is that he WAS a DE, according to DD, and he now teaches
at Hogwarts, obtaining the post of potions master right before LV's
fall. Why did DD do that? Why did he allow him to teach at the
school? Perhaps 'allow' isn't the right word. Maybe we need to be
broaching this one from the same perspective as Trelawney,
protection. Before LV's return, how many former (Free) DE's sat
around talking about the old days? Is their any reference to Snape
and Lucius discussing the Dark Lordthingy? If Lucius and whoever
else believed that Snape had turned traitor before LV's return,
wouldn't he need protection also?
Flitwick. Some have argued that he's half elf. The apptitude for
charms, the short stature, the squeaky voice. I don't think I've
been able to find a consensus on non-domesticated house elves, but
if there isn't such a thing; if all elves (Half or less) are
required to be subservient to wizards, wouldn't it be reasonable to
assume that if people were to know his true heritage (Sound like
anyone we know? Anyone, say taller and wider than a 'normal' man?)
wouldn't he be in danger of being 'enslaved'?
Fierenze. This one's a gimme. He came to Hogwarts to help out DD,
and now he can't return to his home in the forest. The castle
definitely serves the function of protection for Fierenze.
Hagrid. He was allowed to remain at Hogwarts after his expulsion in
his third year as gameskeeper. But, really, where else could he have
gone? His dad died, his mum was off in the mountains. Perhaps he
could've gone to join her. But, if Hagrid's 'tale' is accurate, how
long would he have survived living amongst creatures even bigger
than him? And, when Hagrid came to get Harry in the beginning of
Book 1, the people on the underground were extremely wary of
Hagrid's size. So, living as a muggle, like his dad, is pretty much
out of the question. Where else could Hagrid have gone?
It's been emphasized over five books just how safe Hogwarts is.
We've seen the castle used as a hiding place for the philosopher's
stone in book 1. Not to mention Harry. Harry is safe there. I just
don't think he's the only one benefiting from it's many spells and
enchantments and 'protection'
Can anyone else think of someone who may have may have been placed
at Hogwarts for their own protection?
McGonagall? Sprout? Pomfrey? Vector? Filch?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive