Comparisons

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 89827

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "quigonginger" <quigonginger at y...> 
wrote:
> 
> Not to put words into your mouth, but that to which you may (or may 
> not) be referring could possibly be Lupin's expression of surprise 
> that Harry heard James:
> 
> PoA US paperback, p.240-1
> "I heard my dad," Harry mumbled.
> (Harry pretends to tie his shoe)
> "You heard James?" said Lupin in a strange voice.
> (On to limited discussion about Lupin knowing James.....)
> 
> There has been discussion on the list about whether or not Lupin was 
> surprised at this.  I believe is spawned the "Lupin is James" theory.
> 

Yeah. Thanks. That's most probably what I was trying to remember.
Not post-graveyard at all, but still a possible hint that there was 
something unexpected about Harry seeing James' image.

Not exactly easy to determine a lot from just "in a strange voice", but
entire edifices of theory have been built on less.

Whatever, I'm not happy with the lack of detail regarding the GH event
and I like it even less when DD  is the sole uncorroborated source. It 
makes me twitchy. How the hell is he so certain as to what happened?
Who told him?

Kneasy