Were Dumbledore & Snape involved in James & Lilly's death+ LV downfall?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 90023

Hi!

You know, after OoP I won't be surprised if your theory will turn out 
to be true. I believe Dumbledore to be capable of anything now.

But if you are correct, I also think that Dumbledore deserves to die 
slow and painful death right now. :o)

Politics are dirty, fight against the evil powerful wizard can't be 
bloodless, unfortunately, but I believe that there is always a line, 
which even a leader in a war can't cross, or he will be no different 
than Voldemort. I think that consciously allowing Voldie to kill 
James and Lily will be that line.

Considering the fact that JKR once called Dumbledore "epithome of 
goodness" (more like an example of extreme stupidity, if you ask 
me :o)), I doubt that he did that.

I am more in agreement with Melclaros' theory that Snape was the one, 
who overheard the complete prophecy and told it all to Voldie, 
setting the said chain of events in motion. I also think that when he 
changed sides , he confessed to Dumbledore, but they were unable to 
save Potters.

If it is true, I still can't wait for Harry's reaction. If it is 
true, I am sure that Severus does feel guilty about it and I really 
want Harry at least once to taunt him, regardless whether he decides 
later to forgive him or not. ( I actually think he will, eventually)


As I said though, I think it is very possible that you are correct.

Alla