Sirius revisited

smartone564 deyerlejm at aol.com
Thu Jul 1 05:21:23 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 103837

> Alla:
> 
> This is the only moment, where I confess I am not quite clear about 
> something. No, I am not questioning Sirius' motives. I suspect it has 
> more to do with Rowling's not fully explaining the situation yet.
> 
> Why, why why was he so sure that Voldemort will never come after 
> peter? Did he consider Voldie to be stupid? 


Thats some really interesting stuff you guys bring up.  However, 
most of it seems moot.  Can Harry still talk to dead people 
through the veil?  Lovegood seemed to say this, though I'm sure 
JKR did this just to annoy us, since Luna has a way to believe 
things with no proof.  However, Sirius idea was that LV would 
never even look for Peter because he was so weak, and 
supposedly insignifigant.  I mean, if you had some gigantic 
secret object you needed to protect, would you give it to Neville 
(who is remakably similar to Peter)?  No, Sirius's idea was that 
LV would never suspect something like that, and the plan only 
got foiled because Peter was with LV.


"smartone"






More information about the HPforGrownups archive