Why did Snape teach Occlumency?
demetra1225
tzakis1225 at netzero.com
Thu Jul 1 16:37:37 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 103912
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dnp1234" <davyval at c...> wrote:
> Voldemort must think that Snape has Dumbledore's confindence if he
is
> a teacher. Snape could easily explain to Voldemort that he is
> purposely making Harry fail with his lessons.
Demetra:
But that scenario would mean that Voldemort knows that Snape is an
Occlumens. In my mind, the only way Snape can be spying is if
Voldemort has no clue that Snape is an Occlumens.
I think Sonja was asking why let Snape teach Harry occlumency because
then Voldemort would find out that Snape is an Occlumens and has been
lying to him. If Voldemort was able to perform Legilimency on Harry,
I would ask the same thing.
But the link between Harry and Voldemort is not one in which
Voldemort "reads his mind". As far as we know through the link Harry
has sensed Voldemort's emotions, Harry has seen Voldemort's
activities in real time (the Snake attacking Arthur) and Voldemort
has placed a vision in Harry's head. No evidence that Voldemort has
performed Legilimency on Harry except for perhaps the one time in
PS/SS when he surmised that "He lies." But they were face to face,
this was not done through the scar link.
I guess this brings me back to my question about the whole thing.
Why was it so important for Harry to learn Occlumency, when what he
needed to block was not Legilimency?
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive