They have some detail terribly wrong...

[Susan]

No: HPFGUIDX 103919



> > "peter_jacobi.rm" 
 wrote:
> 
> > > But what about Mad Eye? Was there a hint I missed?
> > I feel the 
> > > reader has the "right" to get some hint, however
> > subtle it is.
> > > After the great revelation the reader should be
> > able to say:
> > > "I should have known!"
> > > 
> > The only clue I can think of is the flask. 
> > Crouch/Moody was always 
> > drinking out of his own silver flask that he carried
> > around.  
> 
> Also, there was "Moody's" comment about "that's when I
> open my trunk" and Snape talking about the missing
> boomslang skin (Moody took it recently, though
> Hermione did steal some two years prior) and that
> "Moody" didn't use his lie-detecting items, but passed
> off the reason as kids lying about homework.
> 
> 
> Rebecca
> 
> =====
> http://wychlaran.tripod.com

I feel like I should have known when HP sees Barty Crouch on the 
Marauders' Map, then runs into Moody.  Crouch is so sick that he 
can't even go into work, and has "Weatherby" doing all his errands 
for him, but yet he's well enough to go running around Hogwarts at 
night?  I'm not saying I should have known it was Barty Jr, but I 
should have known something was amiss.  I took it at face value that 
is really *was* Barty Crouch!
Susan:-)