How about Dobby for the Half Blood Prince

[Phil Vlasak]

No: HPFGUIDX 103983


>Udder PenDragon wrote:
>
>We seem to think that the HBP appeared and had a role in Book 2. What 
>about Dobby we know nothing of his origin and for a House Elf he is wierd. 
>Could he be our HBP?
>
>TTFN           UdderPD
Now Phil continues:
Will the real Half Blood Prince stand up?
What?
He is?
Dobby is the Half Blood Prince!
Here are the reasons why:
1. Since he was at the Malfoy Mansion for years, he would know all about 
their other dark items.
  2. Maybe he was James Potter's House-Elf before the house blew up.
3. He could Apparate into the Riddle House and spy on what LV is doing.
4. He knew about the Room of Requirement, so what other secrets does he 
know at Hogwarts?
And, finally,
5. What other live character has green eyes like Harry?
Answer, Dobby!

Smiles, Phil Pickle


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]