The Floo Network and the Gryfindor Common Room

smartone564 smartone56441070 at aol.com
Sat Jul 3 07:42:32 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104171

> Asian_lovr2:

> As far as Molly calling or students calling home, I would 
counter by
> asking how often you called home when you were in college, 
or boarding
> school if you went to boarding school? Not very often I think,
> probably no more than was mandatory. 

Also, think about the number of students in each house.  How 
would it be reasonable to talk to your son/daughter if there are 
something like (using Harry's male year as a standard, 5* 2 
genders * 7 years= ) 70 students for each house, and 280 in the 
school.

Which also asks the question, what if two (or more) people try to 
Floo talk to the same fireplace? Do they both show up?

> What was
> Umbridge planning to do if she did manage to get hold of 
Sirius's
> head? I really don't think she could have pulled him through 
and into
> the Hogwarts castle. That seems to go directly against 
Hogwarts
> protections. 

Her own office was unprocteced, as you mention later.
 
> So, I'm back to her holding him until he could be traced, or she 
could
> summon help to go make the necessary changes to the castle 
protections
> and Floo Network so Sirius could be captured. 

What if she had decided to hold on to try and follow him through 
to his own location?  This would mean his attempts to flee her 
would help her get through.

Though again, this begs the question, can you Floo into a 
secret-keeper house/place? If not, can you atleast appear in the 
fire and talk?  But I doubt JKR thought too much in this direction.

Smart






More information about the HPforGrownups archive