[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry will die

sp. sot. griffin782002 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 3 16:12:17 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104190

"chbagirl05" wrote:
> So personally, I think Harry will die at the end of all this. I know
> that sounds a bit harsh, but I truly believe Harry would be happier if
> he did.

Sherry wrote:

>I would be highly disappointed, if Harry dies.  But if he dies and it's
presented as making him happy, I would be disgusted.  He will only be 17 at
the end of the books, and lots of kids read these books.  It would be truly
horrible, and absolutely outrageous to tell kids that one of their heroes
found it happier to be dead.  There is already far too much teenage suicide.
It's a tragedy in the real world, and I'd hate to see anything encourage
>that.  
>



Griffin782002:
I believe that Harry might not die. It has been mentioned too many times in the books and with all these 'prophecies by Prof. Trelawney it has become too obvious. And in these books most of the time what is obvious doesn't happen. My bother says it is a possibility, but a horrible one.

Also, in the 19th century Arthur Conand Doyle, killed off Sherlock Holmes. Then, there was a public outrage and he was forced to bring him back. Imagine what will happen if J.K.R. decides to kill off Harry.

"Griffin782002"





More information about the HPforGrownups archive