Some Serious points in favour of Sirius

lavaluvn lavaluvn at yahoo.com
Mon Jul 5 09:31:40 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104391

Amey wrote:
> 
> > The gift of Firebolt is his way of showing his affection (and not 
> apology for attacking Ron as some suggested)
> 

Smart wrote:
> Who says Sirius ever attacked Ron?  True, he entered with force 
> (but to a painting, not that hard for Filch to 'expertly' re-
finish), and 
> was standing over Ron with a knife, but did he ever hurt Ron?  
> Let me think..... uh..... Nope, never touched him, he in fact ran 
> when he was discovered.  Remember, he was looking for 
> Scabbers here, and NOT Ron.  Had Seamus owned Scabbers, 
> (and Sirius found out about it elsewhere) he would have been 
> standing over Seamus's bed, looking for Scabbers.


Andromeda here:
 Well, Sirius did drag Ron into the Shrieking Shack and break his 
leg, right?  I suspect that is the act for which he might want to 
apologize.  Although I think he did apologize.  But I, too, think he 
just wanted to give Harry a nice present after being out of touch so 
many years and to say "thanks for saving my soul from being sucked 
out of my body". He did give Ron the owl (Pig) as a consolation prize.

Andromeda - knowing that others will probably reply before mine gets 
posted; my Elf is probably still asleep like the rest of world when 
you're up late in Hawaii time.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive