JKR's chills

aggiepaddy aggie at raggie.freeserve.co.uk
Mon Jul 5 19:39:11 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104451

Re the 'chills' for JKR from the PoA film, I have re-watched the film 
and noted some of the occurences that happen in the film but not in 
the book:  These are in no particular order but my fave is number 1.

1) Sirius comes back as a dog, permanently!  He says about James 
preferring him as a dog and wanting him to stay that way, but that's 
not in the book.  I don't know how that would work though!!

2) That the R/Hr Ship is-a sailing!  Whenever she gets a chance she 
holds his hand/ hugs him etc.  I know the H/Hr shippers will say the 
same but I feel (and got the impression from the books esp. GoF) that 
it would go R/Hr.  I guess we see what we want to see more than 
anything else!  To the poster (sorry, can't remember who) who 
mentioned about Hermione falling on Harry in the S/Shack, when 
Hermione falls on H, he is facing the ground, surely if this was an 
indication, he'd be facing her? Just MHO

3) Hermione becomes a werewolf!! Lupin bites her during one of his 
monthly outbursts! She bayes at Lupin in the film and not in the book 
(I think)    ;-))

4) The Fat Lady becomes an opera singer!!  With that wonderful voice 
of hers that can shatter glass, she could go far!!!!!!

That's all for now folks!

Aggie    






More information about the HPforGrownups archive