Wands was:Re: CoS clues to Books 6 & 7 analysis

[jastrangfeld]

No: HPFGUIDX 104502

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "smartone564"
<smartone56441070 at a...> wrote:

> 
> Ok, I probably missed this somewhere, but this is the second or 
> third time I have heard that Lily's first wand went away? What 
> happened to it, or where is that thread?

Olivander mentions her first wand as being excellent for charm work. 
I don't know but that must mean something along the lines of she had a
second one at some point.  I just looked it up and the reference is
that it seemed like it was yesterday she was "buying her first wand."
 Whether this pertains to it just simply everyone has a "first" wand,
or there was a later one, I can't say for sure.  My point was the
"excellent for charm work" reference :)


> Do you mean to say, that LV tried to use Lily's wand to AK Harry, 
> but that the same wand had put a protection over him?  
> Therefore, some damage (like the scar, house going boom) and 
> protection (didnt kill him, hurt LV) occured?

That is exactly what I'm saying!  I figure somehow there may have been
a scuffle, and he couldn't reach his own wand, and ended up grabbing
Lily's.  So what do you think? If hers was excellent for charm work,
there's no reason she wouldn't charm it to protect her kids? 
"Childproofing" comes to mind as well.  :)

Julie