Who are Sirius Black and Severus Snape

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 104513

Lady McBeth wrote:
snip
 3.)Snape taunts Sirius endlessly 
> about being useless, their rivalry continues where it left off.  
We 
> never find out who is the better man due to the fact that Sirius 
is 
> now dead. Except!  4,5,&6) Ah yes Sirius risks himself by going to 
> the Ministry to save Harry, while Snape remains undercover and 
does 
> NOT put himself at risk to save Harry Potter.

Potioncat:
In a team effort, every member has a role. Sirius really should have 
stayed at Grimmauld Place and briefed DD. Or certainly, someone 
other than Kreacher should have been there.  I think the Aurors 
should have insisted he stay.  As for Snape, who knows how he felt 
about it?  He would have done more harm to the Order by being at the 
battle, than by staying at Hogwarts. As it stands now, he is still 
usefull.   While I understand why Black went to the DoM, I know he 
shouldn't have.


Lady McBeth:
snip
  The only conclusion I've come to is that I trust 
> Snape; not because of Dumbledore, but rather because of Hermione.  
> She's always right.  I'm putting odds on 
> her being right in this case.  
> Lady McBeth, sick of all the fighting, but probably adding fuel to 
> the fire

Potioncat:
I have a match!  I think Hermione knows something about Snape that 
she isn't telling.  He really should be nicer to her.

Potioncat