Harry uses Hermione's wand to kill Volemort?
anasazi_pr
srobles at caribe.net
Tue Jul 6 00:33:45 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 104541
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "hermionekitten9"
<kreneeb at h...> wrote:
> Sorry, excuse my ignorance... but I don't recall a time when Harry
> ever uses Hermione's wand, more or less a time when he achieves
> a "powerful spell" from using her wand... in the books or in the
> third movie, could you elaborate?
Actually, that's not the scene I was refering to. The scene I was
refering to occurs in the shrieking shack. After Snape comes into the
room as in holding Sirius and Lupin at wandpoint, Harry reaches
around Hermione's waist and grabs the wand she has tucked on her
right pocket (there's even a closeup of the shot). She doesn't
notice, but Ron does and he reaches up and pulls Hermione's sleeve so
Harry can get better access.
When Harry uses Hermione's wand for an Expeliarmus spell, he manages
to knock Snape several feet from the ground and throw him on the
other side of the room, unconcious.
This is the same result we get get in the books when ALL THREE OF
THEM (R/Hr/H) cast Expeliarmus SIMULTANEOUSLY on Snape.
The post originally belonged to the PoA foreshadowings subject, but
it was changed by the list elves. I just thought it was a very
strange change to make (it wouldn't have been so difficult to
replicate the scene from the book!), and thought that might have been
one of the things that gave JKR's chills.
Anasazi
P.S. There are many screenshots of this scene around the web. I'm
sure a little search can help to refresh the memory.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive