[HPforGrownups] Re: HBP and COS

[Miller, Gina (JIS)]

No: HPFGUIDX 104592

Wasn't Seamus' parental revelation in PS/SS? He said his "Mam was a 
with and his father was a Muggle." I don't remember a CoS discussion 
about this.

I'm not saying it isn't him, just that the revelation was in the 
first book.

Casey

Gina now:
  This is an odd post for me, but has anyone thought maybe Dobby was not
always an elf? I will not be disappointed if you throw tomatoes because I do
not really love the idea, but what if Dobby was a human at some point put
under a spell or something crazy like that?
 
 Gina - who named her dog Dobby 


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]