About Sirius, Wormtail, Snape, Draco

[Phil Boswell]

No: HPFGUIDX 104595

"Amey Chinchorkar" <sherlockholme_ac at r...> wrote:
[snip]
> Amey again [talking about the difficult-to-squash wand-order
controversy]:
> That only states the correct order, and also the spells coming out
> don't give us the timing. I was talking about that, not the actaul
> Lily-First-James-Later-Or-Vice-Versa thing. Sorry, it was getting a
> long post and I wrapped up the point. What I meant was that there
> seems to be some doubt that the man was not James. 

Sorry but I just boggled and I wanted a sanity check.

I am not aware of any possible reason from canon to doubt that the man
who appeared from Voldemort's wand in the graveyard scene was anyone
other than James Potter.

JKR on her website has now --- after a bit of jiggery-pokery to make
sure the animated and text versions are consistent with each other ---
confirmed that Lily appeared first, followed by James, and that he was
therefore killed before her (presumably very shortly or at least with
no intervening murders).

This would appear to be concrete proof that James Potter did indeed
die at Godric's Hollow, just as Voldemort confirmed.

Which man are you saying "was not James"?
-- 
Phil