The FAQ says "Lily first"

[Geoff Bannister]

No: HPFGUIDX 104674

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, garyfredogal at h... wrote:
> > Geoff:
> > Yes but if you accept the above canon (PS "The Man with Two 
Faces" 
> > p.213 UK edition), you can't object to the Lily first theory. 
> > The "echoes" appear from the wand in the order, last first, 
Cedric 
> > being in that position. Therefore, as has been indicated, Lily 
must 
> > come out of the wand first because she died after James.

garyfredogal:
> No, I am objecting to the posts that say that Lily *died* first, 
not 
> that she came out of the wand first. Of course if she died before 
> James she would arrive before James.

Geoff:
Hang about, you're still not right unless you haven't expressed your 
thought clearly. If Lily died before James, James would emerge from 
the wand /first/. That doesn't seem to be the drift of your 
comment....