[HPforGrownups] JKR requested bat shot in PS/SS film was Re: JKR's input on film scene at GH

[fridwulfa hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 104708


We know that the scene where we see Lily's being murdered, the flashback,
contained, at first, the murder of James too. JK asked especifically that
only Lily should be seen. That reinforced the idea that the male voice Harry
hears when the dementors approach him "It's him, Lily, take Harry and
run..." was not James's, that James was maybe already dead and there was a
third person in the house. Snape and Lupin are the favourite theories.
Cheers,
Fridwulfa