CHAPTER DISCUSSION: Chapter 22 - St. Mungo's Hospital

mcmaxslb McGregorMax at ec.rr.com
Wed Jul 7 01:51:17 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104711

hebridean_black_dragn wrote:> > Do the adults (and Moody in > 
>>particular) really care about Harry as a person, or do they mostly 
> >>see him as a pawn in the fight against Voldemort? To what degree 
is > >Harry receiving (or *not* receiving) support from the adults in 
his life?
>

 
> Meri wrote: To take on both these questions, I would say that Harry 
is not 
> recieving much support at all from the grownups in his life, and 
> that that lack of support and information and such was what drove 
> Harry to be ever so angry at the begining of Order, not some raging 
> teenage hormones. One of the reasons that DD wanted Harry raised 
> away from the WW was so that Harry would become more than just 
> the "one with the power..." and now that that he is his own man, 
the 
> adults in his life must accept that he's not just passive. He's got 
> to be active or he'll go crazy and take people with him. Although I 
> think that the list of adults who truly care about Harry is fairly 
> short: Mr and Mrs Weasley, DD, McGonogall, Sirius, Lupin, Hagrid. 
> That's about all. 







One of the things that always bothered me about the HP series was the 
lack of support that Harry receives. It not so much the fact that he 
has been sent back to the Dursleys, but the fact that he is abandoned 
there is what gets me. And if the Order just leaves Harry at Privet 
Dr. to stew in grief and guilt, well JKR says that this summer will 
be Harry's shortest stay with the Dursleys that you wonder is they 
have to take him out because he hurts himself.  McMax.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive