Wands was:Re: CoS clues to Books 6 & 7 analysis

[jastrangfeld]

No: HPFGUIDX 104714

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "jimlaming" <jlaming426 at a...> wrote:
> smartone564 wrote:

> Jim remembers:
> IIRC during the duel in the graveyard, when Harry's and Voldie's wand 
> are having the Priori Incantatem effect, both James and Lily come out 
> of Voldie's wand.  That wand was the wand that killed them.  (With 
> Lily dead, even if there was a struggle, he has time to pick up his 
> own wand.) After Lily comes out of the wand, came the failed AK.  
> What does a failed AK look like?  See the discussion back at #103409 
> and several splinter threads around there.  
> 
> I believe it was Voldie's wand all along.
> 
> Jim Laming

>From what we've seen of wizard duels/fights recently, it has been
shown that wands can be whipped out of other people's hands and then
another grabbed.  Just because Lily and James were killed with that
wand, does NOT mean that it happened before the AK.  If someone else
were there to pick up Voldemort's wand, say, Pettigrew? . . . And
finish off Lily.  Perhaps Pettigrew does this just to finish covering
his tracks.  I suppose if Lily were unconcious and Voldemort in a
hurry . . . I still see it as a possibility.

Julie