No Mark Evans (Was: Privet Drive / Ethical Legilimency /)
justcarol67
justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 7 02:38:22 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 104720
Carol:
I for one expect to see little Mark in the Sorting Hat scene in Book 6
and believe him to be a distant relation of Harry's (whom Dumbledore
doesn't know about about because his parents are Muggles).
"smartone" responded:
I would just like to ask, why wouldnt Dumbledore know? He seems to
know pretty much everything else. However, I must admit, you might be
on to something here.
Carol says:
Hi. I just wrote you a very long post explaining how IMO Dumbledore is
not omniscient and how he could be unaware of a ten-year-old
Muggleborn in Harry's neighborhood, but when I checked my e-mail I
found a message urging me to go to JKR's site and read the response to
the FAQ Poll.
What a crushing discovery! Mark Evans is nobody! My favorite non-Snape
theory reduced to ashes! And I was so looking forward to "seeing"
Harry and Mark staring open-mouthed at each other at the Sorting
ceremony. I guess I'll hunt up Madam Pomfrey and see if she'll place a
cheering charm on me.
Carol, who will try to go back to lurking now and make the List Elves
happy. (Maybe they'll pose for a photo in their tea towels and post it
to the list. *That* would cheer me up.)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive