Luna is very strange, was The Prophecy: Harry's interpretation and reaction

vmonte vmonte at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 7 04:12:32 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104736

Alora wrote:

I do like Luna, and I, too, think she has a very spiritual take on
things. But, why is her character so....odd? I don't get why she
has to be someone that people giggle at or make fun of. I mean, JKR
could have done that same thing with the character without making
her look like a fool that believes crazy things.

All I know is that I will go mad if she and Harry end up together.
Not that Harry needs to end up with any girl, but NOT THAT ONE.


vmonte responds:

She is a little wacky, but I like that she is an individual. What I 
don't like is the CD reading of Luna in OOTP by J. Dale(?).  The way 
he read Luna was really creepy.  His interpretation of her sort of 
reminded me of wacko Trelawny. But to be honest even Dumbledore has 
moments were he comes off as being a bit wacky: "Nitwit! Blubber! 
Oddment! Tweak!" SS page 123, U.S. version.

vivian

P.S. I don't think that Harry and Luna are going to end up an item 
either.
 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive