[HPforGrownups] JKR requested bat shot in PS/SS film...

[fridwulfa hagrid]

No: HPFGUIDX 104768


----- Original Message ----- 
From: "Arya" <dequardo at waisman.wisc.edu>
To: <HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Wednesday, July 07, 2004 4:59 AM
Subject: [HPforGrownups] JKR requested bat shot in PS/SS film...


> "fridwulfa hagrid" <yutu75es at y...> wrote:
> >
> > We know that the scene where we see Lily's being murdered, the
flashback,
> > contained, at first, the murder of James too. JK asked especifically
that
> > only Lily should be seen. That reinforced the idea that the male voice
Harry
> > hears when the dementors approach him "It's him, Lily, take Harry and
> > run..." was not James's, that James was maybe already dead and there was
a
> > third person in the house. Snape and Lupin are the favourite theories.
> --------------
> Arya responded:
> Here I go, debunking....counter my points if you can.  :D  Here's the
thing--I don't see
> how that voice could have been Snape's or Lupin's of all the people (other
than the
> most likely--that it is just simply James).  See, in the book, Hary hears
'a new voice, a
> man's'.  How could Harry not hear that voice and, if it was Lupin, not
immediately
> recognize it as Lupin's when Lupin is then the very next person to talk to
him?? And if
> it was Snape's, how could Harry, who's heard Snape yell more than almost
anyone,
> not recignize the voice as the very distinctive voice of Snape's?
>
>
Me (Fridwulfa)
I'm not saying I believe this theories to be true, I was just explaining
that some people believed them to be a possibility. What's for sure is that
something happened with James. "He put a corageous fight", said Voldemort.
Something of importance happened before he tried to kill Harry and Lily.
What, I don't know. We'll have to wait, I guess, in order to find out.
CHeers
Fridwulfa