[HPforGrownups] Dumbledore evil??

[mainecoon at wytopitlock.dk]

No: HPFGUIDX 104817

Hi Maren

I agree with you that Dumbledore isn't that perfect as the general opinion seems
to be, but I don't agree with you that DD isn't there on purpose whenever happens
around Harry.

Maren:
> The first book he was called away on importaint duties.

DD didn't know what was happening at Hogwarts and went of just to take care of
his job. He came as soon as he realized that something was totally wrong.

Maren:
> and the fourth he wasn't there for the graveyeard part

DD couldn't be there as Harry was brought to the graveyard with a portkey

It's not realistic to believe that DD can be everywhere whenever Harry is in
trouble. As the matter of fact Harry seems to have a ability NOT to tell DD when
something is up.

But but but, I went quite angry with DD after reading book 5. He is very selfish
and thinks more of what he thinks is right to tell Harry than just tell Harry
what he ought to know. Ok, DD admits that he should have told Harry the truth a
long time ago, but Harry can't use that to anything!
I still have a feeling that DD hasn't told Harry everything.

Anette