Ringdear of the Marauders: Sirius or James? (was Kreacher the Murderer)

[cubfanbudwoman]

No: HPFGUIDX 104877

Bren:
>>> But that is *another* point I wanted to address. What made Sirius 
WORSHIP James? Peter "hero-worshipped" James and Sirius according 
to McGonagall (or was it Madam Rosmerta...), but why Sirius?
Seems like he had everything a typical teenage boy wanted.<<<

Then SSSusan:
>> Except, perhaps, a loving family and a happy home life devoid of 
prejudice & the dark arts?<<

Now Eustace_Scrubb:
> Well, hey, Regulus didn't think it was so bad, did he now?  What was
> wrong with Sirius, anyway, the malcontented delinquent!  He was
> probably just fine until they sent him to that school...what _do_ 
> they teach them in these schools?
> 
> Eustace_Scrubb
> (who's just kidding, but may run to the asbestos-covered shelter 
> just in case anyway)


SSSusan again:
[Chortle.]  No need to run from ME over this, Eustace. :-)  I'm so 
befuddled about my own feelings & thoughts regarding Sirius right now 
that I couldn't flame anyone unless they came out and said "Sirius 
was THE worst character we've met yet." 

Hmmmm.  Kneasy?  You wanna take that one one?

Siriusly Snapey Susan...who really MUST get to work before she gets 
sacked.