Theory: Dumbledore to Teach Defence Against the Dark Arts?
Steve
asian_lovr2 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 7 23:34:57 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 104934
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "peter838169" <pete_larkin at b...>
wrote:
> Steve/asian_lovr2 wrote:
>
> > For the record-
> >
> > I think HARRY is the JINX on the DADA teaching position. The bad
> > luck began when he arrived, and when Harry is finally gone from
> > school, the bad luck on the job will go with him.
> Pete:
>
> Is that true? I'm sure I remember reading Fred and George said it's
> always been jinxed? Maybe not. Is there any proof?
>
> Pete
Asian_lovr2:
In the first book, after Harry meets Quirrel, Hagrid discusses
Quirrel, and among other things, he talks about how he relates to his
students. Percy also makes reference to Quirrel teaching in previous
years (highly paraphrased). Although, we don't know how many years, we
know that Quirrel was DADA teacher at least one year before Harry
arrived.
Quirrel gave the impression that he had had bad luck, which turned him
into a frightened quivering person, but we now know that that was just
a front to cover up the fact that he was now loyal to and working for
Voldemort.
So, clearly before Harry arrived, the DADA teacher lasted more than
one year. But no teacher has lasted since Harry arrived at the school.
Just a thought.
Steve/asian_lovr2
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive