Homosexuality in HP (was Re: Ringdear of the Marauders: Sirius or James?)

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 8 02:07:15 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 104960

snip.


 Katie previously:
> > 
> > Wayyy back, somebody posted a message to the effect of "I don't 
see 
> > why JKR would put homosexual characters in the books. It wouldn't 
> add anything to the series." A rather common sentiment, actually, 
and 
> one I absolutely loathe. I mean, imagine putting any other minority 
> in that sentence.
> > 
> > Anyway.. I read Sirius and Lupin as gay (in OOTP). Perhaps 
reading 
> > too much between the lines, but it seems evident to me. 



Alla:


Katie, whether JKR was teasing or not in OoP, I agree that it could 
be read as Sirius and Remus being together and I applauded her for 
that, even though Sirius and Remus are not my favourite slash couple, 
I much prefer well done Sirius/Snape. :)


I doubt that she will make any of the characters openly gay, mainly 
because she has enough battles to fight with the people, who are 
prejudiced against the books for religious reasons, etc.

But I think that she may surprise us still.

snip.

> Brenda :
 huge snip.
 
> > My favorite scenario is that Sirius' name is cleared in the next 
book 
> (and Wormtail exposed under Verisaterum), First Class Order of 
> Merlin, and during his funeral, we see multitude of his ex-lovers 
> weeping for him. (LOL, what kind of movies have I been watching, 
you 
> might ask!) 
> 



Alla: LOL! I want Snape to be one of them. :) 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive