Homosexuality in HP (was Re: Ringdear of the Marauders: Sirius or James?)
Marny Helfrich
marnyhelfrich at comcast.net
Thu Jul 8 10:41:46 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 105092
Sad1199:
> Why should there be any homosexual relationships in the book at all?
> Unless HP is gay, there is no reason to have any kind of homosexual
> relationship anywhere else. I mean, if Sirius was gay (I say not!)
> how would that affect the end of the series? JKR does not seem the
> type to have unnecessary relationships and/or characters in her
> books, so why bother?
>
Why should there be any heterosexual relationships? How does Harry/Cho or
Ginny/Michael Corner/Dean affect the end of the series?
Love relationships are part of the human (and apparently Wizard) condition,
and while the books are primarily about the plot, they are also about the
characters and their development. Romantic relationships are an important
part of that.
Moreover, JKR has made a deliberate point to show the diversity of the
Wizarding world. How does it affect the end of the series that Dean and Lee
are Black, Cho Asian, Parvati and Padma Indian (or Pakistani, maybe), etc.?
Why shouldn't sexual orientation also be part of this variety?
:)
Marny
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive