Who's "that awful boy"...

[Brenda M.]

No: HPFGUIDX 105133

>>> Casey wrote: I'm new here, and have only scanned the latest 
page, so my apologies if someone else has already addressed this 
issue. <<<

Bren now:

Welcome aboard, Casey! Yes, it was discussed by some members over 
the past month that I became acquainted (that's an underestimation, 
more like obssessed) to HPFG. But it is quite a job trying to catch 
up with all the old posts and the search archive doesn't work 
properly for me anyways. So I have learned to embrace my thick skin 
and post a message/thought that potentially had been discussed 
numerous times, lol.


>>> Casey: [on Petunia's comment of "that awful boy"]
> I have a theory about Snape (yes another Snape theory!) that may 
tie into this. Anyone else wondered if Lily weren't actually talking 
to Snape or even LV when Petunia overheard the dementor 
conversation? <<<

Bren now:

You are quick to catch up! Yes, Snape was the one HPFG members 
suspect to be "that awful boy". As for canon, sorry I can't remember 
much. But I do remember someone reasoning that Snape's greasy hair 
is more apt for the "awful" comment than neat/tidy James. And the 
rebuttal argument was that Petunia would have regarded ANY 
wizard/witch to be "awful", no matter how they behaved or presented 
themselves.

Bren