Snape's Destiny/JKR quotes

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 105170

> Melanie wrote:


snip.

> My guess is, one good flashback of Snape crucio-ing a Muggle 
toddler 
> will be enough for even the most die-hard Snape advocates to start 
> looking over the evidence for the Defense. And while I think Snape 
> is endlessly entertaining and a complex character if there ever was 
> one, anybody who's done torture/murder/what-have-you with a smile 
on 
> their lips and a song in their heart is not going on my Christmas 
> card list.
> 
> Oh, and I'm new here, so Hello! :-)
> -Melanie


Alla:


I tell you one thing. Since I love redemption in the fictional 
characters, I can forgive him being a DE (only by value of him being 
a fictional character :)), but if we will know for sure that he 
participated in killings, I will be wanting to ask Snape apologists 
why is it easier to forgive a former murderer than a former school 
bully. Even if Sirius planned to kill Snape, which I don't think was 
true, this is soo not the same.