Goyle was not at MOM and is not in Azkaban

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 105418

<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:

> Carol:
 But what about the Baby-headed Death Eater? I know that someone on 
this list did a lot of thinking about his identity and came up with 
either Rabastan Lestrange
> (and I don't think it's him because I think he was in a threesome 
with Rodolphus and Bellatrix after his partner fell) and one other 
person on the list of twelve. But if the names are given after the 
DE gets stuck in the time warp or whatever it is, isn't it still 
possible that it's Goyle? Otherwise Gregory Goyle's decision to stay 
on as one of Draco's cronies doesn't make much sense. Or rather, 
Draco and Goyle Jr. might have shunned *him.* There's also the 
possibility (dare I say it) of a flint--a simple oversight? JKR 
intended to include him in Malfoy's list but inadvertently left him 
out? (After all, if she can confuse the order of James' and Lily's 
deaths--and throw this list into confusion for two days--she's not 
infallible.)
> 


Valky:
I think Carol, that this reads much more like a deliberate puzzle 
than a Flint.
It has logic puzzle written all over it, I think, now that I've had 
a good look, like Snapes Philos Stone protection.
'scuse me while I get out my pencil.