Sirius revisited--emotional maturity

[justcarol67]

No: HPFGUIDX 105549

> Valky:
<snip>
> 2 Although it fits nicely with the probability that Sirius is 
> unhappy to be losing his guests at the end of Christmas, it also 
> fits, curiously, that he becomes once again hotheaded and recklessly 
> behaved when Kreacher returns.
> 
> 3 We are treated to, in a previous chapter, an insight into the uses 
> of scurvy grass, lovage and sneezewort, which I will quote for you:
> 
> "These plantes are efficacious in the inflaming of the braine, and 
> are therefore much used in Confusing and befuddlement Draughts, 
> where the wizard is desirous of producing hot-headedness and 
> recklessness ...." <snip>

Carol responds:
But note the key word "wizard." We have no indication that House Elves
can brew potions and Sirius would certainly be suspicious if he caught
Kreacher anywhere near a cauldron, not to mention that it would be
hard for Kreacher to obtain these plants and Sirius would be highly
unlikely to eat or drink anything that Kreacher gave him. Also, the
effects of most potions don't appear to be long-lasting--at least the
wolfbane and polyjuice potions are temporary. I imagine the effects of
a befuddlement draft would also be fleeting.

I think that Sirius' temperament, environment, and circumstances are
sufficient to explain any shifts in his mood and behavior in OoP.
Think what he was like in PoA. Without his friends and trapped in that
terrible house, he's slipping back in that direction. Expecting a
stable Sirius is like expecting a saintly Draco. It's not going to happen.

Carol