Was Harry Born a Muggle?

gelite67 gelite67 at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 11 05:02:22 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 105594

My personal theory as to why LV couldn't kill Harry:  Snape was there 
and interfered b/c he was in love with Lily.  He arrived too late to 
save her, but he saved Harry so that part of her would live on.  

My alternative theory is that LV got it wrong and Neville was the 
person referred to in the prophesy.  Harry was born a Muggle but 
became a wizard when LV transferred some of his powers to him (marked 
him as his equal).  LV could only kill the infant who was mentioned 
in the prophesy; since Harry wasn't the infant, LV couldn't kill 
him.  There are references to LV killing Muggles, but no other 
references to him killing infants, I don't think.  

Just a theory . . . ready to be shot down.

Angie






More information about the HPforGrownups archive