COS musings/questions (long)

[Adan]

No: HPFGUIDX 105598

leb <lbiles at f...> wrote:

<snip other questions>

> In a later book the sword of Gryffindor is displayed in a glass 
> case in DD's office.  Was the sword always on display there or 
> did Harry summon it out of thin air when he literally pulled it 
> out of the hat in CoS and now DD has it encased as an heirloom
> keepsake. Since the hat and the sword both belonged to Godric then 
> it could be plausible that it materialized from nowhere instead of 
> being summoned from DD's office.


Well, I don't think that it was ever concretely pointed out that 
there was a sword in Dumbledore's office, so it's hard to say if it 
was there. Personally, I think Harry *did* just pull it out of the 
hat.

Adan, thinking the sortings were probably much more comfortable after 
that...