Snape questions
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Sun Jul 11 15:26:47 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 105630
Del wrote:
> So it could be that Snape is not such a good Legilimens. I know he
> always seems to know when Harry has been lying, but that could
just be
> good psychology or something like that. And I guess it must be even
> harder to use Legilimency when excited, stressed or angry.
>
> Just my guess,
>
Potioncat:
I think you're right. We're told he's an Occlumens, not a
Ligilimens. There are several times in the books where I think he
is trying to get eye contact with Harry in order to work Legilimens,
but I'm not sure if it works.
I haven't double checked the canon version, but it appears that is
what he is up to in the scene with Filch's petrified cat. (in the
movie at least) And again in GoF when he sits across from Harry
and hisses insults at him. At that time, Harry tries to avoid eye
contact.
It would also make sense, since he is merely a lad of 35 or so,
that he might just be starting to work on Legilimens. DD, afterall
is 150.
Potioncat
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive