Ron's "Fake" Predictions (Re: "childproofing" wands, and Neville in GoF)

Jenni A.M. Merrifield strawberry at jamm.com
Sun Jul 11 18:26:38 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 105640

Lene' wrote:
> One other thing sprang to mind this afternoon as I read GoF. Did 
> FakeMoody use Imperio or some other nefarious bit of business on 
> Neville when he invited him in for tea after upsetting him during 
> class by showing the Cruciatus curse on the spider? I note that it 
> isn't long after this that Ron makes one of his "fake predictions" 
> in which he tells Harry to beware of a friend who 
> is going to backstab him. 
[...snip...]

  Ya know... Crouch!Moody was a "friend" to Harry - helped him with 
the tasks, gave him advice, didn't rat him out to Snape when he was 
stuck on the stairs under the invisibility cloak.  And Crouch!Moody 
definitely stabbed Harry in the back.

  Has anyone combed through the books in an attemt to enumerate how 
many of Ron's "fake" predictions have actually come true versus how 
many have failed?

Jenni
(who wanders off, muttering in a voice that sounds vaguely like 
Capt. Jack Sparrow: "that's very interesting...")





More information about the HPforGrownups archive