James the Berk

[ladyramkin2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 105644

Charme (hi Charme, welcome) wrote:
>Could you imagine how freakedthe Griffinders would be, hearing 
Snape, of all people, having a choice (of house)...

I take it that by the Griffinders, you mean Sirius, James & co. But 
how would they know if Snape was making a choice.  When Harry was 
muttering "Not Slytherin" I presume only the Sorting Hat could hear 
him.  If Snape was muttering "Not....whatever he wanted or didn't 
want, surely the same would apply.

You go on

>This also could be part of the reason he hates Harry so - Harry made 
a decision that Snape himself could not.

Again, how would he know what decision Harry had made, if only the 
Hat could hear him?

Sylvia (who heartily endorses the motion that James is a berk, but 
hopes our American cousins realize that this is Cockney rhyming slang)