Thestrals Seen by 4th Years (was Re: Boggart/ Patronus Musings - Quote Lupin)

halli hallisallimalli at yahoo.com
Sun Jul 11 21:34:45 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 105675

Ginger:
> As for Luna and the Thestrals, I think the answer may lie in the 
> fact that Luna has been able to see them since she got there. Either 
> she knew before she got there (perhaps Dad prepared her?) or she 
> asked once she got there and found that she was the only one, or one
> of only a few, of her peers who could see them.  For all we know, she 
> may have told Ginny about them.  

 
  Halli:
   Well that would make sense, except that when Ginny and Luna talk 
about them, they normally say "Hagrid says" so I'm pretty sure he 
taught them about them. Maybe he taught that year because of Luna 
and they all thought she was crazy(er than usual) because she could 
see them...I'm not that great at guessing like this.
 oh well
   Halli 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive