James the Berk?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 105699

Batchevra at a... wrote:


> Lupin told us that Snape had seen Madame Pomphrey take him to the 
Whomping 
> Willow to transform, and was interested where he went. Granted 
Sirius never told 
> Snape what was going on, but told him how to get through the 
Willow. What 
> Snape should have known is that the teachers were somewhat already 
informed about 
> something that should have been kept quiet.Yes, Sirius sent Snape 
to the 
> Shrieking Shack, but Snape was partly at fault for going. 
> 
> Batchevra
> 
> 


Alla:


Without speculating about Sirius' reasons for ding what he did, 
without reiterating once again about "bad blood" between Sirius and 
Snape, I will partially agree with you:


Unless we learn that Snape was under Imperium curse, he had NO 
BUSINESS going into Shack, absolutely NONE.


He was desperate to learn Lupin's secret to have them all expelled?

Well, he got more than he bargained for. No, he did not deserve to be 
eaten by Werewolf, but if he went into Shack of his own free will, he 
was WRONG in doing so.